Douglas Milewski (dacuteturtle) wrote,
Douglas Milewski
dacuteturtle

Roberts Was Right

The Robert's court has held up the subsidy provision of Obamacare.

Putting on my Conservative upbringing hat (which I keep around for such occasions), he was right to do so.

Literalism sounds like a good idea in law, but in practice, it just doesn't work. As Roberts indicated, many parts of the law were "inartfully drafted." If the court had found that that particular clause could be interpreted differently due to a flaw in the drafting, then every law could be held to the same scrutiny, with every flaw being held accountable. The results would be judicial gridlock as every flaw in every law became actionable.

Even worse, new laws would see more suits than old laws. Imagine being a conservative, getting your law passed, then having it torn apart by your opposition for every grammatical mistake and drafting oversight. Your attempt to implement a truly conservative government would grind to a halt. The effort to defeat one law would lead to countless conservative defeats in the future.

The truth is that law isn't dictum, law is dialog. Law exists in a relationship between the writers, the implementers, and the court. Laws aren't merely words on a piece of paper, they are interactive bits of government and society that work through a common understanding. Because no law is without flaw or error, the system needs a reasonable threshhold of imperfection so that the laws can operate toward their intended goal as the drafters intended.

If humans could draft perfect laws, then yes, literal reading would be useful. Humans aren't perfect. Laws aren't perfect. In that context, a literal reading of the a law is an impossible ideal.

Subscribe

  • Moving to DreamWidth

    For those heading to DreamWidth, I've created an account. I'm dmilewski.

  • Prostitution as a Means of Family Planning

    Does prostitution constitute a method of family planning? If a man doesn't want more children, then instead of having sex with his wife, he has sex…

  • The Swordbearer (1982)

    The Swordbearer (1982) by Glen Cook is the dark fantasy version of a YA novel. If you know Glen's writing style, you'll recognize the disaster about…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments