Douglas Milewski (dacuteturtle) wrote,
Douglas Milewski

Further into Education

I am further into The Underground History of American Education. I have hit the place where he talks about psychology and psychological research into learning. It is here that I see the deepest problems with this work. They are deep enough for me to question its integrety.

The authors description of pschychogists and their research into learning desmonstrates only a basic psychology textbook understanding of learning and learning research. Much of his discussion on child development boils down to "it's invalid because you can't just stuff kids into cans that way." That is to say, he has no actual idea on the research that has actually occurred in this area. He has no idea that most of this has little or nothing to do with school style learning. This is from a person who claims to have studied psychology and this area of psychology.

In fact, what his is doing is attacking psychology in general, which demonstrates to me that the research itself is not very easy to attack. This puts up a big beware sign. I find it amazing how shallow his argument become the moment he talks about a subject in which I am informed.

I could tear this work down further, and certainly freshen up my rhetoric, but I don't feel like doing that. However, I will continue reading this work with a deeper skeptical eye.

  • Weekend

    Laundry. Bread. You know the drill. Aggie was over, playing with my daughter all day and generally aggravating mayhem. My daughter has been tearing…

  • Weekend Wrap

    In baking, I made bread, mini cinnamon rolls, and chocolate chip cookies. Several times over the weekend, the over didn't come up to temperature…

  • Snow in March

    Of all things, a major snowstorm in March. It's not deep for us, but there's more than enough slush and ice to go around. Getting to work proved easy…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded